sustainable tourism Archives - Silvica: Blog for Sustainable Development http://silvica.site/category/sustainable-tourism/ Greening our world through content Thu, 30 Nov 2023 18:37:28 +0000 en-US hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=6.7 https://i0.wp.com/silvica.site/wp-content/uploads/2019/05/cropped-silvica_image.jpg?fit=32%2C32 sustainable tourism Archives - Silvica: Blog for Sustainable Development http://silvica.site/category/sustainable-tourism/ 32 32 162136420 Fair and Transparent Benefit Sharing In CBT http://silvica.site/fair-and-transparent-benefit-sharing-in-cbt/ Thu, 30 Nov 2023 18:35:27 +0000 http://silvica.site/?p=1491 CBT is a promising segment as modern tourists are looking for unique and authentic experiences

The post Fair and Transparent Benefit Sharing In CBT appeared first on Silvica: Blog for Sustainable Development .

]]>

By David Okul

The participation of local communities through sharing the benefits of tourism is one of the major characteristics of community participation in tourism. The benefits that can emanate from CBT activities include amenities, facilities, income, and employment opportunities. As the community expands, local governments provide additional budget in forms of road improvement and direction signs in and around the community.

Among the most common problems with CBTOs in Africa, and probably the world, is the benefit-sharing mechanism. In many cases, CBTOs would function efficiently until money, or other forms of benefit, comes in. It is important for a CBTO to develop and agree on a benefit-sharing mechanism before embarking on the CBT journey. 

 

 

 

Local culture is a common CBT attraction

How can a CBTO ensure benefit sharing?

The first step for an effective benefit-sharing mechanism in the CBT is to have an identifiable membership for the CBTO. It is common for CBTO members to register with a CBTO and pay predetermined membership fees. Additionally, communities should be able to identify their stakeholders with clarity

  1. Well-established institutions: Members of any community have different backgrounds and interests. It is important that they have a legitimate local community institution that is respected by the community and provides an interface for engaging with other stakeholders such as investors and local governments.  A CBTO can establish committees to deal with various issues that are pertinent to its operations.
  2. Well defined property rights. The CBTO resource inventory should be documented and the members made aware of their ownership and power rights.
  3. Local communities must get genuine benefits from community-based tourism activities in their localities. A sharing procedure must be defined and communicated to all stakeholders beforehand. Table 6.1 below shows how a CBTO can share benefits that accrue from hiking activities

Table 6.1: A simple benefit-sharing mechanism for a CBTO

A CBTO charges KES 1000 for a hiking experience to a local hill. The benefits are shared as follows:

  • KES 300 provides local motorbike transport and water for the hiker (30%)
  • KES 200 is a guiding fee for the guide (20%)
  • KES 150 is given to the owner of the land where the hill is located (15%)
  • KES 100 is sent to the tour operator or the referral who brought the client (10%)
  • KES 250 is retained by the CBTO for administration (licenses and office space) and the rest is retained as profit that will be shared as a dividend at the end of the year.
  1. If communities are denied fair and transparent benefit-sharing procedures, it is likely that conflicts will arise in the CBT.
  2. Assist the community in improving their access to basic services (such as water, sanitation, education and hygiene). This can be achieved by the group undertaking activities related to corporate social responsibility.
  3. Establish schemes to assist the vulnerable members of the community (e.g. disabled, orphans, widows)
  4. Encourage basic training of business operations to CBT staff and owners e.g. in aspects of cash flow, budget surplus/deficit, and retaining part of the profits to reinvest

Concluding remarks

Benefit sharing is a make or break for community-based tourism projects. Transparency is key in ensuring a fair framework. A predetermined benefit sharing is most ideal, from my experience. However, some CBT enterprises choose having a board to distribute benefits.

David Okul is a Kenyan environmental management professional with over 10 years experience on donor projects, conservation, forestry, ecotourism, and community-based natural resources management. When not working on  environmental projects, I spend my time writing for Silvica on a variety of topics. The views in this blog are personal and do not represent the organizations that he is associated with. 

The post Fair and Transparent Benefit Sharing In CBT appeared first on Silvica: Blog for Sustainable Development .

]]>
1491
Social Well Being and Human Dignity In CBT http://silvica.site/social-well-being-and-human-dignity-in-cbt/ Tue, 31 Oct 2023 18:28:18 +0000 http://silvica.site/?p=1483 CBT is a promising segment as modern tourists are looking for unique and authentic experiences

The post Social Well Being and Human Dignity In CBT appeared first on Silvica: Blog for Sustainable Development .

]]>

By David Okul

A CBT project is sustainable as long as it produces a net positive benefit to the community. In general, the objective of community-based tourism development is to improve the community’s level of economic, social, and environmental advancement. Examples of benefits include the creation of community resources such as health services, education, and infrastructure for the community itself. In addition, CBT must benefit all stakeholders involved for it to last. The benefit enjoyed by the local community usually comes in the form of financial and non-financial gains.

Subsequently, rural and community-based tourism could increase the opportunities for social contact and exchange among the local community and the visitors. In addition, rural tourism benefits the community as it focuses on the protection and preservation of local nature and heritage.

Local culture is a common CBT attraction

How can a CBTO ensure social well-being and guarantee human dignity?

  1. Develop a social policy with the community members and proactively communicate and update periodically. A CBT social policy should:
  • Respect local cultures by ensuring that the activities undertaken by the CBT should not undermine their culture or the cultures of neighboring communities
  • Promote gender equality by practicing equity in the distribution of roles and resources to women, youth, and men.
  • Uphold dignity and respect i.e., apart from local cultures, the CBT has to make efforts to respect and treat with dignity the cultures of its visitors.
  • Support child protection whereby the CBTO ensures that the social policy protects children from negative aspects of sex tourism and child labor.
  1. Promote Collaboration and networking. This is consistent with principle 2 for CBT. Collaboration and networking ensure that the CBTO understands stakeholders’ need for social well-being.
  2. Implement efficient marketing strategies: A CBTO needs to be market-efficient to be able to sustain its social activities. Information on effective marketing methods can be obtained from the SUS-TOUR Marketing Guidelines[1] and the SUS-TOUR DIY toolkit on Marketing.[2]
  3. Promote the conservation of natural resources. Conservation of community resources needs to be one of the main characteristics of sustainable tourism development. In this subject area, conservation refers to the preservation of the culture of a local community, the heritage in the area, the environment, and nature that represents the identity of the tourist place. Ventures that promote conservation promote the social well-being of the community. More on conservation is available in principle 8.
  4. Develop a code of conduct for the CBTO members. The code of conduct refers to rules that guide the social norms and practices of groups and organizations. It assists in ensuring that members understand the dos and don’ts of an organization.
  5. Develop a code of conduct for tourists. CBTOS needs to have a code of conduct as visitors may have cultures and beliefs that are dissimilar to them. Each CBTO should develop a code of conduct and communicate it to the tourists during the initial briefing.
  6. Develop a code of conduct for the other business activities including food and beverage, guides, accommodation, etc. A code of conduct is an important tool in improving the quality of products and experiences offered by CBT.
  7. Discourage the abuse of drugs among the community members
  8. Disseminate information on the contemporary social issues in the area such as HIV and AIDs, tribalism, and corruption as they relate to the CBTO.

[1] Georgina, Guillen-Hanson, Leisinger Matthias, and Deng Yang. 2017. “SUS-TOUR Marketing Guideline.” http://www.sustourkenya.org/index.php/2016-07-01-15-04-15/downloads/send/3-downloads/8-marketing-guideline.

[2]  Yang, Deng. 2018. “SUS-TOUR CBT DIY Toolkit- Module 3: Communication and Marketing.”

 

Sample Code of Conducts

Code of Conducts

David Okul is a Kenyan environmental management professional with over 10 years experience on donor projects, conservation, forestry, ecotourism, and community-based natural resources management. When not working on  environmental projects, I spend my time writing for Silvica on a variety of topics. The views in this blog are personal and do not represent the organizations that he is associated with. 

The post Social Well Being and Human Dignity In CBT appeared first on Silvica: Blog for Sustainable Development .

]]>
1483
Legal Status of CBT In Kenya http://silvica.site/legal-status-of-cbt-in-kenya/ Mon, 21 Aug 2023 17:49:49 +0000 http://silvica.site/?p=1457 Communities are usually excited when starting their new community-based tourism organizations. Consequently, they sometimes ignore the need for obtaining licenses and permits. It is true

The post Legal Status of CBT In Kenya appeared first on Silvica: Blog for Sustainable Development .

]]>

Communities are usually excited when starting their new community-based tourism organizations. Consequently, they sometimes ignore the need for obtaining licenses and permits. It is true that getting licenses and permits is not an exciting undertaking in most cases, but failing to get the permits and licenses from the beginning is one of the most common mistakes a CBTO can make.

Within community-based organizations (CBOs), there are many differences in terms of the organizational structure and size. For instance, some CBOs have corporate registration.

The smaller and informal CBOs are, however, registered by the Department of Gender and Social Development. Most CBTOs in Kenya would fall under the latter. The registration fee is usually five thousand shillings for the option.

How can a CBTO ensure a valid legal status?

  1. At the very basic, the organization should register with the Department of Labour under the Ministry of East Africa Community, Labour and Social Protection to be recognized as a CBO. Among other things, registration would require:
  • Details of the management committee of the CBO including Chairman, Secretary, Treasurer, their deputies, and members.
  • Minutes of the CBO meetings
  • The CBO objectives and activities
  1. Ensure that the CBO renews its membership certificate to the Department of Labour on an annual basis.
  2. Check with the county government if the CBO would need a single business permit
  3. CBOs offering homestays should ensure that they comply the homestay criteria developed by the Ministry of Tourism
  4. Ensure that food handlers have a Health Clearance Certificate from the Ministry of Public Health and Sanitation to ensure that food handlers are free from communicable diseases.
  5. The Health Clearance certificate should be renewed after every 6 months
  6. Check with Tourism Regulation Authority (TRA) for registration status of the CBO. In general, CBTOs would fall under class E of TRA that includes:

Why Register

It is great if your CBT is legally recognized as it opens up doors for doing business. Some organizations or hotels will only work with you if you have proof of registration. In the same way, it is important for the business to have professional documentation such as invoices, delivery notes, receipts etc.

The post Legal Status of CBT In Kenya appeared first on Silvica: Blog for Sustainable Development .

]]>
1457
Partnerships with relevant stakeholders for CBT http://silvica.site/partnerships-with-relevant-stakeholders-for-cbt/ Sun, 23 Jan 2022 04:33:16 +0000 http://silvica.site/?p=1400 CBT is a promising segment as modern tourists are looking for unique and authentic experiences

The post Partnerships with relevant stakeholders for CBT appeared first on Silvica: Blog for Sustainable Development .

]]>

By David Okul

Stakeholder participation has been described as an essential element in successful sustainable tourism development as it helps coordinate and balance decision-making based on the needs and interests of relevant parties. The goal of stakeholder participation is to balance the power between all parties to promote a win-win situation in tourism development. Participation is therefore defined as “a process of involving all stakeholders including local government officials, local citizens, architects, developers, business people, and planners in such a way that decision-making is shared.

'Our success has really been based on partnerships from the very beginning.'
Bill Gates
Billionaire
Local culture is a common CBT attraction

CBT partnerships is a vital piece of success

It is difficult for CBT to make it alone in the journey of tourism. It is always a good idea to seek synergetic partnerships. The partnerships need to build up the CBT.

Most CBT initiatives get initial funding from an external source, such as donors, government, or development agencies. Over time, the resources diminish and the community needs to depend on tour operators for marketing.

The value of partnerships could be vindicated by the fact that it is the Sustainable Development Goal 17.

How CBT partnerships can be developed with relevant stakeholders?

  1. Identify and select local service providers. A CBTO can look for several service providers including tour guides, transport services, farmers (to supply food), caterers, cleaning services, and security personnel. It is important not to compromise on the qualities set when selecting local service providers
  2. Approach the local authorities for partnerships.  The emergence of county governments in Kenya presents an opportunity for CBTOs to collaborate with them. Most county governments in Kenya have a tourism department that can assist CBTOs in various aspects such as marketing, training, and business development guidance. Furthermore, local tourism is a devolved function under the Constitution of Kenya. This provides an opportunity for productive engagement with CBTOs.
  3. Approach other CBTOs in the area. A CBTO stands a better chance of achieving success if it partners with other community-based organizations. For starters, CBTOs should always consider sourcing their goods and services from other CBOs. Moreover, they can partner with other CBTOs if they offer complementary services. It is a good practice to partner with other CBTOs as they might help in referring guests when they have excessive orders.
  4. Partner with the tour operators or tour guides. Tour operators (TOs) with a good understanding of the market demand can plan trips for large numbers of visitors. When partnering with TOs to craft and market unique experiences for the visitors, their business skills and market access can be valuable assets for enhancing CBTOs’ professional operation and marketing activities.  
  5. Develop a formal communication strategy to communicate with stakeholders.  Formal communication channels transmit information such as goals, policies, and procedures for an organization. This information can be delivered through newsletters and official communications. Ideally, a CBTO creates a monthly or quarterly newsletter to communicate the activities of the enterprise. Emails and networks such as LinkedIn are good channels for conveying formal communication.
  6. Develop an informal communication strategy. Informal communication channel occurs in a relaxed atmosphere. Communication through social media networks such as Facebook and WhatsApp can also be used. 
  7. Develop an unofficial communication strategy. This occurs between stakeholders in social functions such as weddings and funerals. CBTO members need to use the opportunities of social communication to enhance the partnership of stakeholders.
  8. Ensure that the CBTO has a communication channel that communicates with the various stakeholders regularly e.g. weekly, monthly, or as the need arises.

Recap

Honestly, creating viable partnerships for CBT initiatives is a complicated task. It may sound simple, but it is not. While working with CBT initiatives in Kenya, I have observed key lessons in creating partnerships:

Lesson 1: keep the interest of the community at the heart of all partnerships. You rather forgo a partnership than commit to a union that may bring discord among the CBT members. It is vital for CBT members to get involved and participate in partnership decisions.

Lesson 2: Delays are inevitable. Some CBT and CBOs are quite informal, as a result, they are not run professionally. It is good to learn to work with delays and unprofessionalism while trying to improve relationships. For CBTs, patience pays

Lesson 3: Develop networks for partnerships. Work at maintaining networks because some develop into viable partnerships 

Tasks for CBT Initiatives

List the current partners of your CBTO

……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….

……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….

……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….

 

List potential partners for your CBTO

……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….

……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….

……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….

 

How does the CBTO communicate to its partners?

……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….

……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….

……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….

David Okul is a Kenyan environmental management professional with over 10 years experience on donor projects, conservation, forestry, ecotourism, and community-based natural resources management. When not working on  environmental projects, I spend my time writing for Silvica on a variety of topics. The views in this blog are personal and do not represent the organizations that he is associated with. 

The post Partnerships with relevant stakeholders for CBT appeared first on Silvica: Blog for Sustainable Development .

]]>
1400
CBT Community Involvement and Participation http://silvica.site/cbt-community-involvement-and-participation/ Wed, 29 Dec 2021 04:03:50 +0000 http://silvica.site/?p=1377 CBT is a promising segment as modern tourists are looking for unique and authentic experiences

The post CBT Community Involvement and Participation appeared first on Silvica: Blog for Sustainable Development .

]]>

By David Okul

Generally, community-based tourism (CBT) involves communities in controlling, managing, and developing their tourism industry whereby tourists and travelers can experience the community’s way of life and consider the social, economic, and environmental impacts of the destination they are visiting.

CBT has been used to describe a broad range of different tourism models. However, it usually refers to tourism that involves community participation and aims at generating benefits for local communities in the developing world by allowing tourists to visit these communities and learn about their culture and the local environment. Community participation in the tourism initiative is central to all definitions, ranging from cooperatives or individually owned and managed businesses, to joint ventures between the community and the private sector.

The two most significant criteria used in the academic definition of CBT are community ownership/management and community benefit

Local culture is a common CBT attraction

CBT Community Involvement is Lacking

In theory, community-based tourism organizations (CBTO) must consult and involve the community in decision-making processes on tourism planning and management that affect their livelihood directly. However, in many cases, the genuine CBT community involvement has been minimal in most parts of Africa. This has been cited as a hindrance to the development of CBT in Africa as many problems associated with community-based tourism can be attributed to the lack of proper participation of the community.

Community involvement and participation in CBT is important because:

  1. Local communities can take part in identifying resources that would be beneficial to tourism.
  2. The success of tourism relies on the goodwill and cooperation of local people because they are part of the tourism product.
  3. Wider participation ensures that the CBT program can benefit from the skills and experience of a broader range of community members.

How are CBT community involvement and participation achieved?

  1. Promote democracy in the running of the CBT activities. This can vary in different cultures but ensuring that the voice of each member/ stakeholder is valued is a good starting point.
  2. Develop a mission statement with the community members to promote community involvement and participation in the CBT initiative. Generally, a mission statement gives purpose to the organization by specifying why the organization exists.
  3. Set the direction for organizational management right from the establishment stage, determining who takes responsibility for the CBT, which members should participate, and who will monitor and audit the CBT. This is important because CBT activities rely on community resources.
  4. Adopt a clear management structure to ensure that the roles of each post for the CBT should be clearly defined to avoid conflict of interest and overlapping responsibilities.
  5. The CBT management and members should promote capacity building. The leadership and partners of CBTOs should often identify the areas where their organizations need increased capacities and implement training/coaching on them. This is more effective if they are members of civil society organizations
  6. Develop a vision statement that promotes community involvement. A vision statement is informed by your mission statement as it describes what the CBTO aspires to be in the future. Defining your vision provides a chance for stakeholders to identify what their intrinsic expectations are and think about how these might be met through joint efforts. A series of community workshops or meetings can be effective to ensure participatory vision development.  
  7. Include activities within its local culture in its tourism activities. These could include food, ornaments, and/or cultural events. This type of activity would promote community involvement and participation as the members would have a sense of ownership.
  8. Hold regular meetings to update CBTO members and community members on the CBTO’s progress and plans for the future. Ideally, CBTO members should meet at least once a month, and the community should be updated at least quarterly.  Each CBTO member should be aware of the financial health and projections for the CBTO.
  9. Ensure that CBTO members and the community are actively involved (in terms of decision making) in the CBTO activities, especially for new activities.
  10. Provide local communities with sufficient information about the tourism industry to be able to make informed decisions regarding how their future might be impacted. Local people should be willing to participate in tourism and be aware of the potential impacts as well as learn about mechanisms to manage the impacts from the very beginning.
  11. The role of the community and the CBTO members should be identified in the CBTO’s documentation such as Business plans, Stakeholder engagement plans, and business plans.

Not as Easy as it may sound

CBT community involvement and participation may appear easy on paper. However, implementing these in a CBT venture or organization may prove a challenge. For starters, most CBTOs often have internal wrangles and are awash with vices such as corruption. Furthermore, studies have shown that participation is limited by the barriers of lack of tourism knowledge, limited finance, peripherality, the marginalization of women, and elite domination. Regardless, stakeholders need to ensure genuine community involvement for a chance of success in any CBT venture.

David Okul is a Kenyan environmental management professional with over 10 years experience on donor projects, conservation, forestry, ecotourism, and community-based natural resources management. When not working on  environmental projects, I spend my time writing for Silvica on a variety of topics. The views in this blog are personal and do not represent the organizations that he is associated with. 

The post CBT Community Involvement and Participation appeared first on Silvica: Blog for Sustainable Development .

]]>
1377
Definition, Characteristics, Principles, and Examples of Community-Based Tourism (CBT) http://silvica.site/definition-characteristics-principles-and-examples-of-community-based-tourism-cbt/ Fri, 24 Sep 2021 09:26:19 +0000 http://silvica.site/?p=1343 CBT is taunted as the future of tourism

The post Definition, Characteristics, Principles, and Examples of Community-Based Tourism (CBT) appeared first on Silvica: Blog for Sustainable Development .

]]>

By David Okul

By definition, a community refers to a group of people with shared responsibilities and the tendency of making decisions by representative bodies.

CBT definition is diverse as various quarters define the term differently. A common feature in the definitions is the observation that travelers connect with the local communities.

Silvica defines CBT (Community-Based Tourism) as a facet of sustainable tourism that is dependent on resources that are either owned or managed by the community or those that are owned by communal stakeholders. It also focuses on tourism activities carried out by individuals within a community which provide returns to the community for the sustainable use of communal resources.

Characteristics of a Functioning Community-Based Tourism Organizations

To further enhance CBT definition, we have identified 4 main characteristics of community-based tourism organizations, initiatives, or enterprises: 

  1. They are led and owned by the community. This means that local people play a leading role in the enterprise and the assets belong to the community. The resources can therefore not be sold off for private financial gains. This also means that their boards are accountable to the communities, mainly because the directors are representatives of the communities;
  2. They are self-sustaining and able to generate profits to be reinvested and/or distributed among the community. Their financial stability arises from their business practice. Even if they receive support from a third party at the beginning, they can sustain themselves after a while;
  3. They are sustainable which means that they equally tackle environmental and social problems in their area. They are also called social enterprises as they can generate many jobs in the community. They can also return benefits to the community beyond creating direct employment for individuals. For instance, they can offer scholarships or subsidized health care.
  4. Have some cultural heritage. The main selling point of CBT is that it allows visitors to immerse themselves in unique cultural experiences of the hosts

Other characteristics of Community-Based Tourism Enterprises are that they:

  1. Allow people to develop as economic decision-makers;
  2. Can devise strategies to cope with competition and can be developed as part of the local development plan, including hybrid models such as collaboration between governments or NGOs with citizens;
  3. Add value to agricultural produce;
  4. Allocate surplus to community projects and other spin-off community enterprises; and,
  5. Provide purposeful employment and cash income for marginalized individuals and actively engage citizens.

Products offered by CBT

Activities for a CBTO will depend on the cultural and natural assets that are at the disposal of the community. Products offered by CBTO can be based on cultural-social resources, natural resources, and others.

Cultural-Social Resource

Cultural resources could be tangible and non-tangible

  • Tangible cultural resources include things like ancient settlements, rock art, historical buildings, monuments, birthplaces of famous people, religious buildings, cemeteries, painting, traditional instruments, jewelry, and various arts and craft
  • Intangible cultural resources include religion, language, rituals, customs, festivals, games, dances, folklore, cooking, and etymology

Natural Resources

They could be based on landforms, biodiversity, and knowledge

  • Landforms attractions include features such as lakes, rivers, forests, springs, volcanos, nature trails, conservancies, protected areas, caves, mountains, orchards, etc.
  • Biodiversity attraction includes wildlife, rare species, plants, and fishes
  • Knowledge of natural resources includes special info on animals and special ways of making dishes.

Other CBT resources

There are various other ways in which CBT can create innovative products. For instance, nightlife, ballooning, boating, rock climbing, mountain biking, horse riding, water slides, malls, casinos, kayaking, etc. Most of the activities are based on recreation and entertainment facilities.

CBT Community involvement and participation is an important principle for success
A women led CBTO meeting in Coastal Kenya

Principles of Community-Based Tourism

Silvica has identified 10 principles for community-based tourism based on the Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN) CBT standards. These principles include:

  1. Community Involvement & Participation
  2. Partnerships with Relevant Stakeholders
  3. Ensuring that the CBTO complies with the legal requirements of its jurisdiction
  4. Social Well–Being and Human Dignity
  5. Encouraging Fair and Transparent Benefit Sharing Mechanism
  6. Promoting Linkages to the Local Economy
  7. Practicing Respect to the Local Culture and Traditions
  8. Promoting Natural Resource Management and sustainable consumption and production (SCP) principles
  9. Enhancing the Quality of Visitors Experience
  10. Promoting Good Governance, Transparency, and Accountability

Ideally, existing, and emerging CBTs should base their operations around the 10 principles that would promote the development of sustainable community-based tourism organizations.

Examples of Community-based Tourism

Based on the CBT definition, there are various examples of community-based tourism:

Promote CBTIs in your travel

From CBT definition, community involvement is vital. On the surface, community-based tourism tends to encourage the connection between the traveler and the host. But it has additional benefits including promoting the conservation of culture and the environment. Additionally, it provides income opportunities for the community members. So, in your next travel, support community-based tourism projects near you.

David Okul is an environmental management professional with over 10 years experience on donor projects, conservation, forestry, ecotourism, and community-based natural resources management. When not working on  environmental projects, I spend my time writing for Silvica on a variety of topics. The view in this blog are personal and do not represent the organizations that he is associated with. 

The post Definition, Characteristics, Principles, and Examples of Community-Based Tourism (CBT) appeared first on Silvica: Blog for Sustainable Development .

]]>
1343
What’s in a name? Can you tell the difference between eco, sustainable, and responsible tourism? http://silvica.site/whats-in-a-name-can-you-tell-the-difference-between-eco-sustainable-and-responsible-tourism/ http://silvica.site/whats-in-a-name-can-you-tell-the-difference-between-eco-sustainable-and-responsible-tourism/#comments Sun, 14 Jul 2019 09:17:04 +0000 http://silvica.site/?p=391 By David OkulJuly 14, 2019 Africa conservation mainly relies on ecotourism, which covid-19 has halted (Image from Pixabay) A brief discussion of the forms of

The post What’s in a name? Can you tell the difference between eco, sustainable, and responsible tourism? appeared first on Silvica: Blog for Sustainable Development .

]]>

By David Okul
July 14, 2019

Alternative tourism forms
Africa conservation mainly relies on ecotourism, which covid-19 has halted (Image from Pixabay)

A brief discussion of the forms of alternative tourism

Any ardent conservationist/traveler has come across the names of sustainable tourism, responsible tourism, and ecotourism. Differentiating the concepts of sustainable tourism, responsible tourism and ecotourism can be confusing. To make it worse, there are even more related concepts in alternative tourism that appear similar. We have outlined the definition of the three key terms and other related concepts of alternative tourism. Also, this article discusses the concept of the three terms.

we offer sustainable tourism consultancy in Kenya on community-based tourism, ecotourism, application of ecotourism kenya awards
Tourism has adverse impacts to the environment as it consumes resources and produces wastes

Tourism has impacts on the people, the planet, and profits. Alternative forms of tourism seek to address some of the adverse impacts o tourism

Sustainable Tourism

The UNWTO (United Nation’s World Tourism Organization) is the authority on sustainable tourism. It defines the term as:

 

“Tourism that takes full account of its current and future economic, social and environmental impacts, addressing the needs of visitors, the industry, the environment, and host communities”

Ecotourism

Many people believe that ecotourism is a subset of sustainable tourism as its niche is natural areas.  The International Ecotourism Society (TIES) defines the term as, “responsible travel to natural areas that conserves the environment, sustains the well-being of the local people, and involves interpretation and education” (TIES, 2015).

According to UAE Ministry of Economics, ecotourism includes various types such as blue tourism (travel to beaches and seas), yellow tourism (travel to deserts), white tourism (travel to ice areas) and green tourism (travel to areas rich in fauna, and especially flora).

Responsible tourism

Some people claim that responsible tourism is synonymous with sustainable tourism. However, the Cape Town Declaration (2002) and the Center for Responsible Tourism defined responsible tourism as. “tourism that maximizes the benefits to local communities, minimizes negative social or environmental impacts, and helps local people conserve fragile cultures and habitats or species.”

Tourists have always been vital in conservation (Image by Ron Porter from Pixabay

Other terms in Alternative Tourism Concept

Apart from the three terms, there are other terms that are concerned with the sustainable development of tourism. Let start with alternative tourism itself:

Alternative tourism: the opposite of mass tourism. Although mass tourism promoted economic development in terms of jobs, it also resulted in negative effects such as economic leakages, environmental, and social impacts. Alternative tourism aims at addressing the shortcomings of mass tourism.

Overtourism: concerned with the excessive number of visitors leading to negative effects on the host and the environment

Voluntourism: The central principle is that the visitors would give back (do charity events) for the communities in the destination.

Community-based tourism: CBT occurs where visitors are hosted by locals. Communities are the key stakeholders in this model where they exercise greater control and get more benefits that they would receive.

Conscious travel/tourism: it has its basis on the corporate social responsibility that favors values-based triple bottom line approach.

Ethical travel: It basically advocates for people to be mindful of travel choices based on moral values and judgments

Slow tourism: advocates for living as opposed to staying in a destination. That is, visitors need to connect to cultures.

Geo-Tourism: while ecotourism focuses on the flora and fauna, geo-tourism adds the dimensions of the abiotic environment.

Pro-poor tourism: Although controversial, pro-poor tourism seeks to put poverty of host communities at the center of the sustainability debate.

Farm tourism: Also called agrotourism and involves green tourism of farms.

Our Take: A discussion of ecotourism, sustainable and responsible tourism concepts

At Silvica, we deduce that the differences between ecotourism, sustainable and responsible tourism are academic. It is evident that all the definition seek to improve (or at least maintain) the hosts’ life, the natural environment, and the visitor experiences.  As such the three terms oppose the principles of mass tourism and are a form of alternative tourism.

Nevertheless, distinctions between the terms are also apparent. The focus of ecotourism is sustainability in natural areas. From the definition, tourism in ‘unnatural’ places such as cities and historical monuments may not fit the definition of ecotourism. The distinction between sustainable and responsible tourism is less apparent in terms of scope. However, we perceive that the major actors in sustainable tourism are the business people while the tourist bears more responsibility in responsible tourism. In other words, destination managers need to make their destination sustainable while tourists need to ensure that their travel is responsible.

Further, Harold Goldwin, an authority in sustainable and responsible tourism makes a distinction between the concepts. He claims that sustainability is a goal which can be achieved when people take responsibility.  In other words, responsible tourism includes all actions (mostly little) that individuals can take to make tourism more sustainable. In contrast, sustainable tourism is concerned with long-term changes in tourism that target at reducing the negative impacts of tourism while promoting the positive ones. Sustainable tourism targets global issues such as climate change.

In a nutshell, sustainable tourism, ecotourism, and responsible tourism share a similar goal. They are all types of alternative tourism based on the principles of the three-pillared approach to sustainability (environmental, social, and economic), although ecotourism has an intense focus on environmental aspects. Both travelers and operators need to ensure that they incorporate principles of ecotourism, sustainable, and responsible tourism to ensure that the travel and tourism industry is improved (or at least maintained) for the benefits of the future generations.

References and Resources

David Okul is a freelance writer, and a PhD student at a Kenyan university

The post What’s in a name? Can you tell the difference between eco, sustainable, and responsible tourism? appeared first on Silvica: Blog for Sustainable Development .

]]>
http://silvica.site/whats-in-a-name-can-you-tell-the-difference-between-eco-sustainable-and-responsible-tourism/feed/ 1 391